Disclosure of Updates to Ongoing Tax Litigations or Disputes
The updates on tax litigations or disputes in terms of sub-para 8 of para B of Part A of Schedule III read with corresponding provisions
of Annexure 18 of the Master Circular are given below: |
| Any Other Information for Disclosure of Updates to Ongoing Tax Litigations or Disputes |
The company has pending tax litigations or disputes for the quarter ending 31.12.2024 |
| Sr. No. |
Name of the opposing party |
Date of initiation of the litigation / dispute |
Status of the litigation / dispute as per last disclosure |
Current status of the litigation / dispute |
| 1
| M/s T V Trading Pvt Ltd |
04-Mar-2017
| Summary Suit No. 5 of 2017 – Summary Civil Suit has been filed before The Court Civil Judge Senior Division at Kalyan by BEW Engineering Pvt. Ltd. (Plaintiff) against T.V. Trading Pvt. Ltd. (Defendants) and their director Mr Nikunj Desai and Twinkle Nikunj Desai Under Order XXXVII of the code of civil Procedure Code 1908 and as per section 55 of Sale of Goods Act for recovery of advance money paid by Plaintiff to the Defendants a sum of Rs. 50,00,000/- as on 18/08/2016 and a sum of Rs. 67,00,000/- as on 22/08/2016 total amount of Rs. 1,17,00,000/- against Proforma Invoice No. 29 Dated 16/08/2016.The plaintiff had asked for quote for supply of stainless steel plates a key raw material from various vendors and an order was placed with the defendants on 16/08/2016 via order No.BEPL/PO/448/2016 amounting to Rs.1,17,00,000/-. Plaintiff paid an advance of Rs. 50,00,000/- on receipt of the advance Mr. Nikunj Desai Director of Defendant company requested for full payment as the price quoted was competitive in nature and is based on receipt of full payment, Plaintiff agreed and the balance payment of Rs. 67,00,000/- was made. In spite of receiving the payment the defendant refused to deliver the material. The defendant behaved with ulterior motive to cheat the plaintiff and never delivered the goods, the plaintiff is claiming an amount of Rs.1,31,04,000/- along with interest of Rs.14,04,000/- from defendant Rs 1,17,00,000/- |
The case / suit for recovery of company money which defendant has never delivered goods to the company the matter is pending before The Court Civil Judge Senior Division at Kalyan and Next date for settlement /recording evidence of plaintiff on February 06, 2025. |
| 2
| M/s KAF Application and Solution Pvt Ltd and others |
26-Dec-2018
| Special Suit No. 366 of 2018 , Special Civil suit has been filed before The Court Civil Judge Senior Division at Kalyan by BEW Engineering Ltd. Plaintiff against M/s KAF Application and Solutions Pvt Ltd (Defendants) and their Director Mr. Alkesh Vishnushanker Thaker and Mrs. Alpana Alkesh Thaker Under section 9 of code of civil Procedure Code 1908 and as per section 55 of Sale of Goods Act for recovery of excess amount paid under Sale of Goods Act. The plaintiff had asked for quote for supply of O ring and other material, the defendants had not supplied the same and sent the bills and same were wrongly booked and during audit it was found that bills are bogus and goods for the same were never supplied and delivered by the defendants. Hence BEW filed the case / suit for the recovery of excess amount paid of Rs 15,96,612/- for which the Defendants has never delivered goods to the company. |
Special Suit No. 366 of 2018 is pending before The Court Civil Judge Senior Division at Kalyan and Next date for recording evidence of plaintiff on March 10, 2025. |
| 3
| M/s. KAF Seal INC and Mrs. Alpana Alkesh Thaker |
17-Jul-2019
| Regular Suit No. 276 of 2019 , Regular Civil suit has been filed before The Court Civil Judge Junior Division at Kalyan by BEW Engineering Pvt. Ltd. Plaintiff against M/s KAF Seal INC (Defendants) and its proprietor Mrs. Alpana Alkesh Thaker Under section 9 of code of civil Procedure Code 1908 and as per section 55 of Sale of Goods Act for recovery of excess amount paid under Sale of Goods Act. The plaintiff had asked for quote for supply of O ring and other material, the defendants had not supplied the same and sent the bills and same were wrongly booked and during audit it was found that bills are bogus and goods for the same were never supplied and delivered by the defendants. Hence BEW filed the case / suit for the recovery of excess amount paid of Rs 3,05,952/- for which the Defendants has never delivered goods to the company. |
The matter is pending before The Court Civil Judge Junior Division at Kalyan and Next date of hearing on March 10, 2025. |
| 4
| Mr. Nikunj Arvindbhai Desai |
24-Sep-2018
| Commercial suit No 809 of 2021 Summary Suit has been filed before The Mumbai City Civil Court at Mumbai by Mr. Nikunj Arvindbhai Desai Proprietor of P.V. Corporation as plaintiff V/s BEW Engineering Ltd. and their Director Mr. Prakash Bhalchandra Lade, Mr. Vithal Dadabhau Khokrale, Mr. Manish Vihal Khokrale , Mr. Rohan Prakash Lade, Mr. Shashank Vithal Khokrale Defendant. Under order XXXVII rule 2 of code of civil Procedure Code 1908 for recovery of amount as per sale of Goods Act,1930. The plaintiff had claimed that he had sold and delivered the goods but defendant never received the goods hence the suit is pending for hearing of summons for judgement the claim amount of Rs 20,52,655/- plus interest @24% p.a of Rs. 12,26,863/- total amounting to Rs. 32,79,508/-. |
The matter is pending before The Mumbai City Civil Court at Mumbai and Now the summary suit convert into commercial suit No 809 of 2021, matter is fixed for defendant evidence / settlement on January 31, 2025. |
| 5
| Mr. Lalit H. Jain |
23-Mar-2021
| Criminal complaint No. 5853 of 2021 under section 138 The Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 has been filed before The 14th Court Metropolitan Magistrate at Girgaon, Mumbai by Mr. Lalit H. Jain Proprietor DLH Stainless Vs BEW Engineering Pvt Ltd and their Director Mr Rohan Prakash Lade. Summons is not yet received. DLH Stainless Proprietor Mr. Lalit H. Jain had send Demand Notice claiming Interest of Rs.16,98,834/- and Demand Notice of Rs. 16,80,709/- against two dishonored Cheques of Rs. 10,00,000/- & Rs.6,80,709/- respectively under section 138 of The Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 through his authorized Advocate Mayur S. Sonawane on 12/02/2021 to BEW Engineering Pvt. Ltd. And their Director Mr. Prakash Bhalchandra Lade, and Mr. Rohan Prakash Lade. Summons is not yet received, however date of hearing as per online status is 04/09/2021. Upon receiving of the false notice we immediately replied through authorized Advocate of Company Pabari Legal Associates and denied alleged liability in toto and therefore the Company has made stop payment of Cheques as on 15/02/2021. In Addition the company has approached to The Senior Inspector of Police Manpada Police Station as well as The Commissioner of Police, Thane District to register FIR under Section 406 and 420, of Indian Penal Code against DLH Stainless Proprietor Mr. Lalit H. Jain. |
Summons is received and now for recording evidence next date of hearing on February 11, 2025. |
| 6
| Mr. Lalit H. Jain |
16-Feb-2024
| BEW Engineering Ltd. Applicant V/s DLH Stainless Proprietor Mr. Lalit H. Jain Respondent Criminal Application 139 of 2024 & 140 of 2024 pending before session court Mazgaon Mumbai on 17/2/2025 against issued process. |
BEW Engineering Ltd. Applicant V/s DLH Stainless Proprietor Mr. Lalit H. Jain Respondent Criminal Application 139 of 2024 & 140 of 2024 pending before session court Mazgaon Mumbai on February 17, 2025 against issued process. |
| 7
| M/s KAF Application and Solution Pvt Ltd |
09-Sep-2021
| M/s KAF Application and Solutions Pvt Ltd Vs BEW Engineering Pvt. Ltd commercial Suit No 729 of 2021 suit filed before the City Civil Court at Dindoshi for demanding of Rs. 33,27,166=77 alogwith 18% p.a since we have file the suit against M/s KAF Application and Solutions Pvt Ltd hence we have file three notice of motion for stay of Suit , Suit barred by law of Limitation as well as deleting director as defendant same is rejected. |
Next date of hearing on January 30, 2025. |
| 8
| Mrs. Alpana Alkesh Thaker |
20-Aug-2021
| Mrs. Alpana Alkesh Thaker prop. Of M/s KAF Seal INC (Defendants) Vs BEW Engineering Pvt. Ltd and their Directors has filed the suit before city civil Court At Dindoshi bearing Commercial Suit No 730 0f 2021 for Recovery of money. |
Next date of hearing on February 11, 2025 for argument and order on notice of motion. |
| 9
| M/s Hikal Ltd |
15-Jan-2024
| Arbitration Application No 23 of 2024 filed by HIKAL to invoke Arbitration Against Advance payment of Rs 60,00,000/-is paid to BEW our counter Claim is Rs 1,74,00,000/- for non performance of contract which was fixed for hearing on 5/12/2024 before Hon’ble High Court, Bombay. |
Adjourned next date and listing any time on board for hearing. |
| 10
| Mr. Nikunj Arvindbhai Desai |
25-Jan-2024
| Mr. Nikunj Arvindbhai Desai as Petitioner V/s BEW Engineering Ltd. and ors writ Petition No 504 of 2024 for quashing FIR Quashing fixed on February 04, 2025 for settlement. |
Mr. Nikunj Arvindbhai Desai as Petitioner V/s BEW Engineering Ltd. and ors writ Petition No 504 of 2024 for quashing FIR Quashing fixed on February 04, 2025 for settlement. |